Drinking & Dragons

User:Mqs/Shugenja: Difference between revisions

From Drinking and Dragons
>Mqs
quick pass 1
>Mqs
mNo edit summary
 
(8 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Potential additions to the Shugenja spell list from SpC. The percentages are my feeling for how well it fits within that element of Shugenja.
Potential additions to the Shugenja spell list from SpC. The percentages are my feeling for how well it fits within that element of Shugenja. Those bolded are my top choices to add.
 
25% - Eh, might fit with a stretch. Usually, fits one aspect of thematics (ie, "earth"), but not the others (ie, "Earth: Earth spells involve resilience and resolve, health
and growth, and the strength of its body." or established styles in the CD list)
 
50% - Fits decently, but other ones are better. Usually, these would be of limited use to the Shugenja's other abilities or fit into another element just as well.
 
75% - A good choice, overall. Some things (often spell level) make me question it though.
 
90% - A near-perfect fit. If anything holds me back, it's keeping the class from having to much in a usually-limited area (ie, abjuring/dispelling).
 
100% - This is definite. Either it's a higher/lower level version of those existing or otherwise indistinguishable from those already there.
 
== Earth ==
== Earth ==
=== 0 ===
=== 0 ===
* '''Caltrops 100%'''
* Stick 90%


=== 1 ===
=== 1 ===
Fist of Stone 100%
* Animate Wood 75%
Foundation of Stone 100%
* '''Backbiter 75%'''
* Beastland Ferocity 75%
* '''Dispel Ward 90%'''
* Cutting Hand 75%
* Fist of Stone 100%
* '''Foundation of Stone 100%'''
* Mage Hand, Greater 90%
* Sandblast 75%
* Scatterspray 50% (or Air 50% Water 50%)


=== 2 ===
=== 2 ===
Earth Lock 90%
* Briar Web 75%
Earthbind 50% (or Air 75%)
* '''Bristle''' 75%
Earthen Grace 100%
* Burrow 75%
Earthen Grasp 75% (or Air 50%)
* '''Earth Lock 90%'''
Earthfast 100%
* Earthbind 50% (or Air 75%)
Hail of Stone 25%
* Earthen Grace 100%
Stone Bones 75%
* Earthen Grasp 75
Strength of Stone 90%
* Earthfast 100%
Tremorsense 90% (or 100% at 3)
* Gembomb 50% (or Fire 50%)
* Hail of Stone 25%
* Mountain Stance 90%
* '''Spell Immunity, Lesser''' 100%
* Stone Bones 50%
* Strength of Stone 90%
* Tremorsense 90% (or 100% at 3)


=== 3 ===
=== 3 ===
Eradicate Earth 75%
* '''Bands of Steel''' 100%
Giant's Wrath 100%
* Cloak of Bravery 75%
Stony Grasp 75% (or Air 50%)
* Crumble 75% (or 100% at 4)
Treasure Scent 75%
* Diamondsteel 75%
Tremor 100%
* Dragonskin 50%
* Eradicate Earth 75%
* Favorable Sacrifice 90%
* Fell the Greatest Foe 50%
* '''Giant's Wrath 100%'''
* Nature's Rampart100%
* Primal Form 50% (or All 90%) - Earth Only
* Shatterfloor 75% (or 100% at 4)
* Stony Grasp 75
* Thornskin 90%
* Treasure Scent 75%
* '''Tremor 100%'''


=== 4 ===
=== 4 ===
Stone Sphere 50% (or Fire 90%)
* Burrow, Mass 75%
Sudden Stalagmite 75% (or 90% at 5)
* '''Backlash 90%'''
Wall of Sand 100% (or 75% at 3)
* Dispelling Screen 75% (or 90% at 5)
* Iron Bones 50%
* Land Womb 75%
* Lay of the Land 50% (or Air 75% or All 50%)
* Metal Melt 50% (or Fire 75%)
* Recitation 75%
* Resistance Greater 90%
* Safe Clearing 75%
* Spell Vulnerability 90%
* Stone Sphere 50% (or Fire 90%)
* '''Sudden Stalagmite 75% (or 90% at 5)'''
* '''Wall of Sand 100% (or 75% at 3)'''


=== 5 ===
=== 5 ===
Stone Shape, Greater 100%
* '''Indominitability''' 75%
Xorn Movement 90%
* Ironguard, Lesser 75%
* Life's Grace 90%
* Plant Body 90%
* '''Poison Thorns''' 75%
* Sanctuary, Mass 90%
* Stone Shape, Greater 100%
* '''Symbol of Spell Loss''' 50%
* Vulnerability 75%
* Xorn Movement 90%
* Zone of Respite 90%
* Zone of Revelation 90%


=== 6 ===
=== 6 ===
Earth Reaver 25% (or Fire 90% at 5)
* Cometfall 25% (or 50% at 7)
Stone Body 90%
* Earth Reaver 25% (or Fire 90% at 5)
Stonehold 75% (or Air 50%)
* '''Hardening''' 75%
Tunnel Swallow 90%
* Resistance, Superior 90%
* Sarcophagus of Stone 75% (This is [Earth] subtype according to errata.)
* '''Stone Body''' 90%
* Stonehold 75% (or Air 50%)
* '''Tunnel Swallow''' 90%


=== 7 ===
=== 7 ===
Stone Spiders 75% (or Water 50%)
* '''Aura of Vitality''' 75%
* Body of War 75%
* Dispelling Screen, Greater 75% (or 90% at 8)
* Elemental Body 100% (or All 90%) - Earth only
* Ironguard
* Maw of Stone 75%
* '''Spell Resistance, Mass''' 100%
* '''Stone Spiders''' 75% (or Water 50%)


=== 8 ===
=== 8 ===
Excavate
* Excavate 90%
* '''Bombardment''' 50% (or 75% at 9)
* Heart of Stone 50%
* '''Unyielding Roots''' 75%


=== 9 ===
=== 9 ===
Transmute Rock to Lava 90%
* Cast in Stone 75%
Undermaster 100%
* Transmute Rock to Lava 90% (or Fire 75%)
* '''Undermaster''' 100%
 
=== Probable But Didn't Think At Length ===
* Attune Form, Planar Tolerance, etc...
* Repair Damage
 
=== Considered Heavily, But Not ===
* Benign/Baleful Transposition
* Hurl (Wu Jen...)
* Slide, Greater Slide


=== Scratch Pad ===
=== Scratch Pad ===
== All ==
* Summon Elemental Monolith 9ish
* Summon Elementite Swarm 4ish
* Summon Greater Elemental 6ish

Latest revision as of 15:38, 21 July 2010

Potential additions to the Shugenja spell list from SpC. The percentages are my feeling for how well it fits within that element of Shugenja. Those bolded are my top choices to add.

25% - Eh, might fit with a stretch. Usually, fits one aspect of thematics (ie, "earth"), but not the others (ie, "Earth: Earth spells involve resilience and resolve, health and growth, and the strength of its body." or established styles in the CD list)

50% - Fits decently, but other ones are better. Usually, these would be of limited use to the Shugenja's other abilities or fit into another element just as well.

75% - A good choice, overall. Some things (often spell level) make me question it though.

90% - A near-perfect fit. If anything holds me back, it's keeping the class from having to much in a usually-limited area (ie, abjuring/dispelling).

100% - This is definite. Either it's a higher/lower level version of those existing or otherwise indistinguishable from those already there.

Earth

0

  • Caltrops 100%
  • Stick 90%

1

  • Animate Wood 75%
  • Backbiter 75%
  • Beastland Ferocity 75%
  • Dispel Ward 90%
  • Cutting Hand 75%
  • Fist of Stone 100%
  • Foundation of Stone 100%
  • Mage Hand, Greater 90%
  • Sandblast 75%
  • Scatterspray 50% (or Air 50% Water 50%)

2

  • Briar Web 75%
  • Bristle 75%
  • Burrow 75%
  • Earth Lock 90%
  • Earthbind 50% (or Air 75%)
  • Earthen Grace 100%
  • Earthen Grasp 75
  • Earthfast 100%
  • Gembomb 50% (or Fire 50%)
  • Hail of Stone 25%
  • Mountain Stance 90%
  • Spell Immunity, Lesser 100%
  • Stone Bones 50%
  • Strength of Stone 90%
  • Tremorsense 90% (or 100% at 3)

3

  • Bands of Steel 100%
  • Cloak of Bravery 75%
  • Crumble 75% (or 100% at 4)
  • Diamondsteel 75%
  • Dragonskin 50%
  • Eradicate Earth 75%
  • Favorable Sacrifice 90%
  • Fell the Greatest Foe 50%
  • Giant's Wrath 100%
  • Nature's Rampart100%
  • Primal Form 50% (or All 90%) - Earth Only
  • Shatterfloor 75% (or 100% at 4)
  • Stony Grasp 75
  • Thornskin 90%
  • Treasure Scent 75%
  • Tremor 100%

4

  • Burrow, Mass 75%
  • Backlash 90%
  • Dispelling Screen 75% (or 90% at 5)
  • Iron Bones 50%
  • Land Womb 75%
  • Lay of the Land 50% (or Air 75% or All 50%)
  • Metal Melt 50% (or Fire 75%)
  • Recitation 75%
  • Resistance Greater 90%
  • Safe Clearing 75%
  • Spell Vulnerability 90%
  • Stone Sphere 50% (or Fire 90%)
  • Sudden Stalagmite 75% (or 90% at 5)
  • Wall of Sand 100% (or 75% at 3)

5

  • Indominitability 75%
  • Ironguard, Lesser 75%
  • Life's Grace 90%
  • Plant Body 90%
  • Poison Thorns 75%
  • Sanctuary, Mass 90%
  • Stone Shape, Greater 100%
  • Symbol of Spell Loss 50%
  • Vulnerability 75%
  • Xorn Movement 90%
  • Zone of Respite 90%
  • Zone of Revelation 90%

6

  • Cometfall 25% (or 50% at 7)
  • Earth Reaver 25% (or Fire 90% at 5)
  • Hardening 75%
  • Resistance, Superior 90%
  • Sarcophagus of Stone 75% (This is [Earth] subtype according to errata.)
  • Stone Body 90%
  • Stonehold 75% (or Air 50%)
  • Tunnel Swallow 90%

7

  • Aura of Vitality 75%
  • Body of War 75%
  • Dispelling Screen, Greater 75% (or 90% at 8)
  • Elemental Body 100% (or All 90%) - Earth only
  • Ironguard
  • Maw of Stone 75%
  • Spell Resistance, Mass 100%
  • Stone Spiders 75% (or Water 50%)

8

  • Excavate 90%
  • Bombardment 50% (or 75% at 9)
  • Heart of Stone 50%
  • Unyielding Roots 75%

9

  • Cast in Stone 75%
  • Transmute Rock to Lava 90% (or Fire 75%)
  • Undermaster 100%

Probable But Didn't Think At Length

  • Attune Form, Planar Tolerance, etc...
  • Repair Damage

Considered Heavily, But Not

  • Benign/Baleful Transposition
  • Hurl (Wu Jen...)
  • Slide, Greater Slide

Scratch Pad

All

  • Summon Elemental Monolith 9ish
  • Summon Elementite Swarm 4ish
  • Summon Greater Elemental 6ish